There is nothing like the suggestion of a canc
问题详情
There is nothing like the suggestion of a cancer risk to scare a parent, especially one of the hyper-educated, eco-conscious type. So you can imagine the reaction when a recent USA Today investigation of air quality around the nation's schools singled out those in the smugly(自鸣得意地) green village of Berkeley, Calif, as being among the worst in the country; The city's public high school, as well as a number of daycare centers, preschools, elementary and middle schools, fell in the lowest 10 percent. Industrial pollution in our town had supposedly turned students into living science experiments breathing in a laboratory's worth of manganese, chromium and nickel each day. This is a city that requires school cafeterias to serve organic meals. Great, I thought, organic lunch, toxic campus.
Since December, when the report came out, the mayor, neighborhood activists(活跃分子) and various parent-teacher associations have engaged in a fierce battle over its validity: over the guilt of the steel-casting factory on the western edge of town, over union jobs versus children's health and over what, if anything, ought to be done. With all sides presenting their own experts armed with conflicting scientific studies, whom should parents believe? Is there truly a threat here, we asked one another as we dropped off our kids, and if so, how great is it? And how does it compare with the other, seemingly perpetual health scares we confront, like panic over lead in synthetic athletic fields? Rather than just another weird episode in the town that brought you protesting environmentalists, this latest drama is a trial for how today's parents perceive risk, how we try to keep our kids safe— whether it's possible to keep them safe—in what feels like an increasingly threatening world. It raises the question of what, in our time, "safe" could even mean.
"There's no way around the uncertainty", says Kimberly Thompson, president of Kid Risk, a nonprofit group that studies children's health. "That means your choices can matter, but it also means you aren't going to know if they do". A 2004 report in the journal Pediatrics explained that nervous parents have more to fear from fire, car accidents and drowning than from toxic chemical exposure. To which I say: well, obviously. But such concrete hazards are beside the point. It's the dangers parents can't—and may never—quantify that occur all of a sudden. That's why I've rid my cupboard of microwave food packed in bags coated with a potential cancer-causing substance, but although I've lived blocks from a major fault line(抵制断层) for more than 12 years, I still haven't bolted our bookcases to the living room wall.
What does a recent investigation by USA Today reveal?
A.Parents in Berkeley are over-sensitive to cancer risks their kids face.
B.The air quality around Berkeley's school campuses is poor.
C.Berkeley residents are quite contented with their surroundings.
D.Heavy metals in lab tests threaten, children's health in Berkeley.请帮忙给出正确答案和分析,谢谢!
参考答案
正确答案:B
根据题于关键词investigation,USAToday定位到原文首段第二句。由…singledoutthoseinthesmuglygreenvillageofBerkeley,Calif.,asbeingamongtheworstinthecountry.由此可知,伯克利校园的空气质量很差。译文:没有什么事情比有得癌症的迹象更让父母感到害怕的了,尤其对于受到过度教育、对生态环境敏感的那种人来说。所以当《今日美国》在近期公布的一份全国范围的学校周边空气质量调查中,[52]把加州伯克利的绿色环保小镇列为全国最差时,你可以想象到那些自鸣得意的人的反应。该市的公立高中以及为数众多的日间看护中心、学前教育机构、小学和中学都在最差的10%之列。我们镇上的工业污染大概已经把学生置于活体科学实验之中,学生们每天吸入等值于实验室剂量锰、铬和镍等重金属。而这发生在一个要求学校的餐厅提供有机饭菜的城市中。太棒了,我想,有机午餐,有毒的校园。[53]自12月份报告公布以来,市长、社区活跃分子和各种家长—教师联合会都参与到一场关于报告的可信度的激烈斗争中:关于位于小镇西北角上的钢铁铸造厂的罪责、有关孩子们的健康与工会职责,以及应该去做的事,如果还有事能做的话。[54]每一方都展示了各自的专家,以及他们互相矛盾的科学研究结果,父母究竟应该相信谁?我们在让孩子下车时会相互询问,这儿是不是真的存在危险?如果真有危险的话,有多严重?和其他危险相比怎么样?比如像综合运动场上铅含量这样我们似乎要面临的永久性的健康恐慌。这不仅仅是发生在城镇中引来一群游行抗议的环保主义者的又一个奇特事件,这场最新的闹剧是对现在的父母如何看待风险的考验,对我们在一个看起来危机四起的世界里如何尽量保证我们孩子安全的考验——无论能否保证他们的安全。由此引发的问题是,在我们的时代,“安全”究竟意味着什么。“没有办法解决不确定的问题,”金伯利·汤普森说,她是一个研究儿童健康问题的非营利组织“孩子的危机”的主席。“这意味着你的选择很重要,但这也意如果你的选择真的很重要的话,你也没有办法知道。”[55]-份2004年发表在学术期刊《儿科》上的报告解释了不安的父母们对火灾、车祸和溺水的恐慌要更甚于接触有毒化学物质。对此我认为:嗯,很明显。[56]但是这些具体的危险并非重点,而是那些父母们不能——可能永远也不能——量化的、突然发生的危险。这正是我已经把所有包装袋上涂有可能致癌物质的微波食品全部扔掉的原因,但是尽管我住在一个距离大地质断层几街区远的地方已经12年了,我仍然没把我们的书架固定在客厅的墙上。